The Wiki for Tale 4 is in read-only mode and is available for archival and reference purposes only. Please visit the current Tale 11 Wiki in the meantime.

If you have any issues with this Wiki, please post in #wiki-editing on Discord or contact Brad in-game.

Difference between revisions of "Talk:Firepit"

From A Tale in the Desert
Jump to navigationJump to search
(moving raw yield data to discussion page)
(Updated yield formulae including papyrus - matches existing data well. Also some speculation about less than full loads)
Line 134: Line 134:
 
== Possible yield formulae ==
 
== Possible yield formulae ==
  
This seems to fit some of the numbers here and matches my own tests. Yield seems to be based solely on elapsed time, not number of stokes, which makes it hard to fit to most of the data here unfortunately (because the time between stokes varies a lot)
+
Using these formulae, and assuming 1 stoke = 45 teppyseconds, I get very good agreement with the data on this page (in general, +/- 1 for 80% of the data, with a few obvious outliers that are probably measurement errors):
  
  t = (burning duration in teppyseconds) / 30
+
  t = int( (burning duration in teppyseconds) / 30 )
  charcoal = t^(1/3) * 11
+
  charcoal = int( t^(1/3) * 11 )
  lime from 100 limestone = t^(1/3) * 6
+
  lime from 100 limestone = int( t^(1/3) * 6 )
  ash from 100 flax = t^(1/3) * 5
+
  ash from 100 flax = int( t^(1/3) * 5 )
  ash from 100 leeks = t^(1/3) * 2
+
  ash from 100 leeks = int( t^(1/3) * 2 )
 +
ash from 100 papy = int( t^(1/2) * 5 )
  
(i.e. yield is proportional to the cube root of duration)
+
i.e. yield is proportional to the cube root of duration for everything except papyrus, which is proportional to the square root. Duration includes the ignition and smouldering-out time (so t=12 for 0 stokes - 6 teppyminutes from ignition to completion).
  
Duration includes the smouldering-out time (so t=11 for 0 stokes). Fractional results are discarded, not rounded up. I haven't tested papyrus yet.
+
I will go ahead and put this on the main page since it agrees well.
  
(bah, <math> rendering is disabled)
+
I have not tested less than full loads yet. However, speculation:
  
--[[User:Inkoaten|Inkoaten]] 06:09, 5 March 2009 (EST)
+
  lime = int( t^(1/3) * int(limestone/16) )
 +
  ash = int( t^(1/3) * int(flax/20) )
 +
  ash = int( t^(1/3) * int(leeks/50) )
 +
  ash = int( t^(1/2) * int(papy/20) )
 +
 
 +
The way to test this would be to try each of these combinations, if anyone wants to have a go:
 +
 
 +
  200 wood + 15 limestone + 19 flax, no stoking
 +
  200 wood + 16 limestone + 20 flax, no stoking
 +
  200 wood + 49 leeks, no stoking
 +
  200 wood + 50 leeks, no stoking
 +
  200 wood + 19 papy, no stoking
 +
  200 wood + 20 papy, no stoking
 +
 
 +
--[[User:Inkoaten|Inkoaten]] 19:33, 9 March 2009 (EST)

Revision as of 00:33, 10 March 2009

Can someone add pictures of the orange - yellow - white stages, and make it a bit clearer when to stoke the fire? It's tough to do with just this info. -shadeking

  • I added information on the color of a fire as well. The Hue of a fire will be 0 during the stoke phase and 60 during the no stoke phase. --Vulpine 18:08, 26 January 2009 (EST)


Data

stokes limestone dried flax leeks dried papyrus -> lime ash charcoal
0 100 100 100 100 13 32 25
0 100 - - - 13 0 25
0 - - 100 - 0 4 25
1 100 100 100 - 13 4 25
15 100 100 100 100 19 51 35
25 100 100 - - 21 18 39
25? 100 100 100 100 22 60 40
30 100 100 - - 22 19 42
30? 100 100 100 100 22 61 41
50 100 100 100 100 26 76 48

Not sure if anyone's collecting stoke data (appears similar to T3). Here's a data point to start with:

200 limestone; 100 dried flax; 200 wood @ 25 stokes (~18 mins) = 21 Lime, 18 Ash, 39 cc

100 limestone; 100 dried flax; 100 leeks; 200 wood @ 1 stoke = 13 lime, 4 ash, 25 cc


Here's my T4 data:

100 limestone; 100 dried flax; 100 dried papyrus; 100 leeks; 200 wood @ 15 stokes = 19 lime, 51 ash, 35 cc

McArine data(not sure about the 30 stoke one being 30 stokes):

  • 100 limestone; 100 dried flax; 100 dried papyrus; 100 leeks; 200 wood @ 0 stokes = 13 lime, 32 ash, 25 cc
  • 100 limestone; 100 dried flax; 100 dried papyrus; 100 leeks; 200 wood @ 25 stokes = 22 lime, 60 ash, 40 cc
  • 100 limestone; 100 dried flax; 100 dried papyrus; 100 leeks; 200 wood @ 30 stokes = 22 lime, 61 ash, 41 cc
  • 100 limestone; 100 dried flax; 100 dried papyrus; 100 leeks; 200 wood @ 50 stokes = 26 lime, 76 ash, 48 cc

More: 100 limestone, 0 stokes -> 13 lime 100 leeks, 0 stokes -> 4 ash

I moved the following data here from the main page so it's all in one place: --Inkoaten 17:19, 9 March 2009 (EST)

Stokes Lime Ash
20 21 52
30 23 n/a
36 26 n/a
40 n/a 72
60 27 n/a
65 n/a 83

--mosen 18:37, 19 January 2009 (EST)

tehmoosh Firetests
Limestone/Papy Limestone/Papy/Leeks
Minutes of
Stoking
Lime Ash Lime Ash
50 27 50 27 58
60 29 54 29 63

Firepit was stoked for the time listed and then allowed to die out. This results in about 5 minutes of additional burn time as the fire dies.

Akmenotep Fire Tests

100 Leeks, 100 Dried Flax

  • 40 Stokes - 28 Ash, 44 Charcoal


100 Leeks, 100 Dried Flax, 100 Papyrus

  • 40 Stokes - 70 Ash, 45 Charcoal


100 Limestone, 100 Leeks, 100 Dried Flax

  • 9 Stokes - 21 Ash, 18 Lime, 33 Charcoal
  • 19 Stokes - 23 Ash, 20 Lime, 37 Charcoal
  • 33 Stokes - 26 Ash, 23 Lime, 42 Charcoal
  • 36 Stokes - 28 Ash, 24 Lime, 45 Charcoal
  • 40 Stokes - 28 Ash, 24 Lime, 44 Charcoal
  • 50 Stokes - 29 Ash, 26 Lime, 47 Charcoal


100 Limestone, 100 Leeks, 100 Dried Flax, 100 Papyrus

  • 33 Stokes - 65 Ash, 23 Lime, 43 Charcoal
  • 40 Stokes - 70 Ash, 24 Lime, 45 Charcoal
  • 50 Stokes - 76 Ash, 26 Lime, 48 Charcoal
  • 60 Stokes - 80 Ash, 27 Lime, ? Charcoal

Speed?

How quickly does the color cycle? I tried once and apparently missed the stoking point entirely, even though I thought I was seeing the color progression. -- Shebi 00:10, 13 January 2009 (EST)

  • The speed will vary, in general the fire will remain in the stoke phase for around 14 seconds after you stoke. The next phase where the stoke button is removed and the fire will change colors seems to be around 5-10 seconds. The no stoke phase that follows is high variable, I have seen it last as little as 5 seconds and go for over 40. --Vulpine 18:08, 26 January 2009 (EST)
  • I used a count of 12 seconds before stoking going 1 and 2 and .... and this worked well for about 10 stokes until my husband walked in. I broke the rhythm but I was able to stoke again about 5 times and then it smouldered out. My yield was between the 10-15 stoke yields. --Dianess 22:34, 5 February 2009 (EST)

Possible yield formulae

Using these formulae, and assuming 1 stoke = 45 teppyseconds, I get very good agreement with the data on this page (in general, +/- 1 for 80% of the data, with a few obvious outliers that are probably measurement errors):

t = int( (burning duration in teppyseconds) / 30 )
charcoal = int( t^(1/3) * 11 )
lime from 100 limestone = int( t^(1/3) * 6 )
ash from 100 flax = int( t^(1/3) * 5 )
ash from 100 leeks = int( t^(1/3) * 2 )
ash from 100 papy = int( t^(1/2) * 5 )

i.e. yield is proportional to the cube root of duration for everything except papyrus, which is proportional to the square root. Duration includes the ignition and smouldering-out time (so t=12 for 0 stokes - 6 teppyminutes from ignition to completion).

I will go ahead and put this on the main page since it agrees well.

I have not tested less than full loads yet. However, speculation:

 lime = int( t^(1/3) * int(limestone/16) )
 ash = int( t^(1/3) * int(flax/20) )
 ash = int( t^(1/3) * int(leeks/50) )
 ash = int( t^(1/2) * int(papy/20) )

The way to test this would be to try each of these combinations, if anyone wants to have a go:

 200 wood + 15 limestone + 19 flax, no stoking
 200 wood + 16 limestone + 20 flax, no stoking
 200 wood + 49 leeks, no stoking
 200 wood + 50 leeks, no stoking
 200 wood + 19 papy, no stoking
 200 wood + 20 papy, no stoking

--Inkoaten 19:33, 9 March 2009 (EST)